The NYC property market in May 2017

What recorded deeds show for May 2017: arm’s-length sales in all five boroughs, from the city’s own records. Figures are frozen as of this edition so they can be cited.

Published
Oct 22, 2026
Deeds recorded through
Sep 30, 2026
Edition
Compiled retrospectively

In May 2017, the median recorded sale price in New York City was $660,000 across 5,154 arm's-length sales, up 7.6% from May 2016. Source: NYC Department of Finance recorded deed sales, as recorded by Sep 30, 2026; not an appraisal.

Median sale price · May

$660,000

+7.6% YoYn = 5,154

Recorded sales

5,154

+5.4% YoYvs 4,888 in May 2016

Dollar volume

$7.7 billion

arm’s-length sales

12-month median

$620,000

+7.4% YoYn = 59,077

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · arm’s-length sales; 12 months to May 31, 2017 · data through Sep 30, 2026 · methodology

The five boroughs in May

Manhattan

$1,200,000

+2.1% YoYn = 1,351

$700K – $2.35M middle half

12 months: $1,100,000+13.7%

Bronx

$425,000

+6.4% YoYn = 437

$230K – $599K middle half

12 months: $400,000+2.6%

Brooklyn

$800,000

+11.1% YoYn = 1,300

$490K – $1.32M middle half

12 months: $760,000+8.6%

Queens

$503,500

+7.6% YoYn = 1,578

$298K – $809K middle half

12 months: $487,000+7.0%

Staten Island

$469,234

+15.9% YoYn = 488

$360K – $623K middle half

12 months: $457,250+10.4%

Bars show the middle half of the month’s sales (25th to 75th percentile) and the median on one price scale; the small charts are each borough’s May median in every year since 2003, on one shared scale, 2017 in navy.

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · arm’s-length sales recorded for May 2017 · data through Sep 30, 2026 · methodology

What the records show

  • $7.7 billion changed hands in recorded arm's-length sales, down 2.5% from $7.9 billion a year earlier; sales were up 5.4%.
  • It was the highest May median on record (since 2003, in dollars of the day, not adjusted for inflation).
  • Manhattan had the highest median ($1,200,000); Staten Island rose most year over year (+15.9%).
  • Over the 12 months to May 31, 2017, the citywide median was $620,000 across 59,077 sales, up 7.4% from the 12 months before.
  • The largest 12-month moves within one property type: up, Brooklyn Heights condos (+88.7%, 131 sales); down, Midtown Cbd condos (−45.0%, 108 sales).
  • The largest recorded deed was $652,000,000 for 85 BROAD STREET (Financial District, Manhattan).

Every statement is computed from this edition’s figures; none is an opinion or a forecast.

May in every year since 2003

Citywide median sale price for May, in dollars of the day.

20032017
May 2017
$660,000 · 5,154 sales
Busiest May
2005 · 7,174 sales

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · May medians, arm’s-length sales · data through Sep 30, 2026 · methodology

May 2017 by property type

Property typeSalesMedian priceMedian $/ft²
Houses (1–3 family)1,891$579,000$363
Condos1,285$980,000—
Co-ops1,282$428,264—
Multifamily382$1,147,500$314
Commercial & mixed-use215$1,600,000$393
Land57$400,000—
Other42$366,378—

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · arm’s-length sales recorded for May 2017 · data through Sep 30, 2026 · methodology

$/ft² only where recorded floor area is reliable (houses, multifamily and commercial buildings, at least 5 sales), never for condo or co-op units, whose deeds carry no unit floor area. See the methodology.

Biggest 12-month moves by neighborhood

The 12 months to May 31, 2017 against the 12 before, measured within one property type so a shift in what sold never reads as a price move. Houses, condos and co-ops, each with at least 50 sales in both periods. New-building closings can still move a neighborhood’s condo median sharply.

Rising
NeighborhoodChange
Brooklyn HeightsBrooklynCondos · $2,849,419 · 131 sales (prior 58)+88.7%
Civic CenterManhattanCondos · $5,065,793 · 295 sales (prior 142)+70.0%
Downtown-fulton MallBrooklynCondos · $1,608,834 · 180 sales (prior 73)+58.6%
Downtown-fulton FerryBrooklynCondos · $1,999,321 · 192 sales (prior 100)+43.3%
GramercyManhattanCondos · $1,940,050 · 140 sales (prior 134)+35.6%
Falling
NeighborhoodChange
Midtown CbdManhattanCondos · $2,062,500 · 108 sales (prior 110)−45.0%
Forest HillsQueensCondos · $510,000 · 73 sales (prior 191)−24.7%
Midtown WestManhattanCondos · $1,327,500 · 444 sales (prior 586)−16.8%
West VillageManhattanCondos · $3,450,000 · 271 sales (prior 316)−16.7%
Cobble HillBrooklynCondos · $840,000 · 70 sales (prior 82)−14.6%

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · arm’s-length sales, 12 months to May 31, 2017 vs the 12 before · data through Sep 30, 2026 · methodology

The largest recorded sales of May 2017

The ten highest arm’s-length deeds dated in May: whole buildings, portfolios and commercial property lead this list, so it describes the top of the market, not a typical home. A deed covering several tax lots is listed once, at one of them.

AddressPrice
85 BROAD STREETMay 24, 2017Financial District · Commercial & mixed-use$652,000,000
107 COLUMBIA HEIGHTSMay 9, 2017Brooklyn Heights · Commercial & mixed-use$87,500,000
15 WEST 44TH STREETMay 18, 2017Midtown West · Commercial & mixed-use$68,000,000
633-635 FULTON STMay 10, 2017Fort Greene · Commercial & mixed-use$68,000,000
43-10 23RD STREETMay 23, 2017Long Island City · Commercial & mixed-use$54,000,000
15 CENTRAL PARK WESTMay 15, 2017Upper West Side · Condos$50,550,000
432 PARK AVENUEMay 5, 2017Midtown Cbd · Condos$44,606,622
537 GREENWICH STREETMay 10, 2017Soho · Commercial & mixed-use$42,641,867
68 FERRISMay 1, 2017Red Hook · Commercial & mixed-use$42,400,000
340 WEST 85TH STREETMay 9, 2017Upper West Side · Commercial & mixed-use$42,000,000

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · arm’s-length sales, no party names · data through Sep 30, 2026 · methodology

About this edition

Compiled retrospectively on Oct 22, 2026, from deeds recorded through Sep 30, 2026: it includes deeds recorded after a timely edition would have been written. The figures above are frozen and will not change.

Arm’s-length sales only: $0 transfers, nominal deeds and statistical outliers are excluded, and a deed recorded once per tax lot counts once. Medians with sample sizes, never averages; not an appraisal. Not affiliated with the City of New York. Markdown version.

We use privacy-friendly analytics to understand how the site is used and how AI assistants send visitors here. No advertising, no data sold. Privacy notice