Which sales count as market sales
City deed records include every recorded transfer, and roughly a third of them are not market sales. In the raw 2016–2025 files, about 31% of rows have a sale price of $0 (the Department of Finance marks these as transfers “without a cash consideration”, e.g. between family members or into an LLC).
Before computing any statistic, we classify every record:
- Zero-price: $0 transfers. Excluded.
- Nominal: $1–10,000. Deed corrections and token-consideration transfers. Excluded.
- Outliers: prices outside statistical fences computed per borough, property type and sale year (below the 0.5th percentile, and at least $15,000; above three times the 99.5th). Excluded from medians.
- Timeshare intervals: weeks sold in hotel buildings, recognised as a hotel lot that sells 50 or more times a year at a median under $150,000. Excluded.
- Co-op block transfers: one transfer-tax return that conveys three or more co-op apartments at once (a sponsor’s or an investor’s block), which the Department of Finance records as a single apartment’s sale at the whole price. The City Register (ACRIS) shows the units. Excluded.
- Multi-lot deeds: a sale of several lots on one deed is recorded once per lot, each with the whole price, so it counts once. Sales on one block on the same day at the same price that the City Register (ACRIS) shows as separate deeds to different buyers, such as a developer’s identical houses, count separately.
- Market sales: everything else. These are the only records behind any published price figure.