186 COLONY AVENUE

House·One-family, two stories (detached) (A1)·10306

186 COLONY AVENUE, Midland Beach, Staten Island (BBL 5038060015) last sold for $485,000 on Feb 15, 2019 (5 recorded sales since 2003). Source: NYC Department of Finance recorded deed sales; not an appraisal.

Last recorded sale

$485,000

Feb 15, 2019

Price / ft²

$485

at last sale

Recorded sales

5

+1 non-market transfers

Assessed value FY2027

$499,000

DOF market value

Recorded sale history

Every deed transfer on record for this lot since 2003, including non-market transfers (marked). Only arm’s-length sales feed our price metrics.

RecordedClass$/ft²PriceStatus
Feb 15, 2019A1$485$485,000Market sale
Mar 31, 2016A1$383$382,500Market sale
Sep 11, 2013A1$80$80,000Market sale
Sep 11, 2013A1—$0$0 transfer
Aug 19, 2010A1$320$320,000Market sale
Mar 29, 2006A1$354$353,600Market sale

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales (ACRIS/DOF) · all recorded transfers; market flag per methodology · data through Oct 31, 2026 · methodology

Not affiliated with the City of New York. Compiled from official NYC Open Data (Department of Finance sales & assessment, City Planning PLUTO & Property Address Directory), provided as-is without warranty. This is a record of transactions, not an appraisal or an estimate of current value. Non-arm’s-length transfers (family, $0 deed corrections, partial interests) are shown for completeness and excluded from price metrics. See our methodology.