Tottenville

Borough
Staten Island
NTA
SI0305
Recorded sales, 12 months
149
Data as of
Oct 31, 2026

In the 12 months to Oct 31, 2026, the median recorded sale price in Tottenville, Staten Island was $980,000 across 149 arm's-length sales, up 22.7% year-over-year. Source: NYC Department of Finance recorded deed sales; not an appraisal.

Median sale price · 12m

$980,000

+22.7% YoYn = 149

Houses · median $/ft²

$442

n = 136

Co-ops · median price

n/a (low sample)

n = 0

Condos · median price

n/a (low sample)

n = 3

Median sale price by year

’03  ’06  ’09  ’12  ’15  ’18  ’21    ’26

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · arm’s-length sales only · data through Oct 31, 2026 · methodology

What sells here

  • Houses (1–3 family)91%
  • Land3%
  • Commercial & mixed-use3%
  • Condos2%
  • Everything else1%

Rental market

Median gross rent
$1,672/mo
Gross rent-to-price yield
2.0%

Gross rent-to-price = ACS median gross rent × 12 ÷ median sale price. It is a neighborhood signal, not a cap rate or investment advice. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2019–2023 (5-year). This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau. Methodology.

Most active in Staten Island

Latest recorded sales in Tottenville

Recent sales citywide →
RecordedAddressType$/ft²Price
Oct 26, 2026250 BRIGHTON STREETHouse · A5$417$667,500
Oct 14, 202678 HONEY LANEHouse · B2$380$995,000
Oct 6, 2026388 SPRAGUE AVENUE, 58 · 58Condo · R3—$250,000
Oct 2, 2026622 MAIN STHouse · A1$481$1,300,000
Oct 2, 20267344 AMBOY ROADCommercial · S2$371$925,000
Oct 1, 2026558 MAIN STREETHouse · B2$350$1,199,999
Sep 28, 2026N/A BRIGHTON STREETHouse · B2$408$1,374,638
Sep 28, 202627 SANDY LANEHouse · A5$372$540,000

Source: NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales · latest 8 arm’s-length sales shown · data through Oct 31, 2026 · methodology

Embed this chart on your site (free, with attribution)

Paste this into your article. It stays live as new sales are recorded:

<iframe src="https://nycpropertymarket.com/embed/area/tottenville" width="560" height="300" style="border:0" title="Tottenville median sale price (NYC Property Market)" loading="lazy"></iframe>

Why do co-ops show no $/ft²?

City records carry no unit square footage for co-op and condo sales. We publish per-unit medians instead of inventing precision.

What counts as a market sale?

We exclude $0 transfers, nominal deeds and statistical outliers, together roughly a third of raw records. Full rules in the methodology.

Where do these numbers come from?

NYC Dept. of Finance recorded sales, refreshed monthly. Every figure shows its sample size and as-of date.

We use privacy-friendly analytics to understand how the site is used and how AI assistants send visitors here. No advertising, no data sold. Privacy notice