Roughly seven in ten Manhattan apartments are co-ops, yet most national price statistics quietly ignore how differently they appear in public records. If you compare condo and co-op figures without knowing this, you’ll draw wrong conclusions.
Condos: real property, own tax lot
Each condo unit is its own piece of real property with its own tax lot (a “unit BBL”). When it sells, a deed is recorded like a house sale. The city’s condominium registry maps ~307,000 unit lots to their buildings. That’s how we group condo sales by building.
Co-ops: shares in a corporation
A co-op “owner” holds shares in the building’s corporation plus a proprietary lease. A sale is a share transfer recorded against the building’s lot, with the apartment number embedded in the address text. There is no unit lot and no recorded unit square footage, ever.
What this means for statistics
- No honest $/ft² for units. Any site showing price per square foot for a co-op (or condo) unit from public records is estimating. We publish per-unit medians instead. See the methodology.
- Co-ops usually look “cheaper.” Same neighborhood, similar apartments: co-op medians run well below condo medians. Maintenance structures, board approval and land-lease quirks are all baked into that gap.
- Automated valuations struggle here. National AVMs are documented to be least accurate on NYC co-ops. Recorded sales are the evidence that actually exists.
Compare them yourself: every neighborhood page shows co-op and condo medians side by side, each with its own sample size.
Frequently asked
- Why don't co-op sales show square footage?
- Co-op sales are share transfers, not property deeds. City records identify the building and apartment number but never the unit's floor area, so honest statistics use per-unit prices instead of $/ft².
- Are co-ops really cheaper than condos?
- Per recorded sales, co-op medians consistently sit below condo medians in the same area. Part is real (maintenance, board rules, financing limits), part is composition: co-op stock is older on average.
- How do I see condo or co-op prices for my neighborhood?
- Every neighborhood page on this site shows separate co-op and condo medians with sample sizes, computed from recorded arm's-length sales.