# 257 POTTER AVENUE

> 257 POTTER AVENUE, Castleton Corners, Staten Island (BBL 5003380034) last sold for $450,000 on May 13, 2004 (2 recorded sales since 2003). Source: NYC Department of Finance recorded deed sales; not an appraisal.

**As of:** Oct 31, 2026  
**Source:** NYC Department of Finance recorded deed sales (via NYC Open Data)  
**Canonical page:** https://nycpropertymarket.com/property/5003380034-257-potter-avenue  
**License:** free to use with attribution to NYC Property Market (https://nycpropertymarket.com)

## Property details

| Metric | Value | Sample |
| --- | --- | --- |
| BBL | 5-00338-0034 |  |
| BIN | 5009208 |  |
| Type | One-family, two stories (detached) (A1) |  |
| Year built | 1915 |  |
| Units | 1 |  |
| Neighborhood | Castleton Corners | Staten Island |

## Recorded sale history

| Recorded | Class | $/ft² | Price | Status |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Nov 23, 2020 | A1 | — | $532,000 (whole building) | Building sale (2 lots) |
| May 13, 2004 | A1 | $326 | $450,000 | Market sale |

## Assessment (FY2027)

| Metric | Value | Sample |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Market value | $976,000 |  |
| Assessed total | $58,560 |  |
| Assessed land | $27,720 |  |

---

_Not affiliated with the City of New York. Figures are recorded-sales evidence with documented limitations, not an appraisal. Only arm's-length sales feed price metrics (≈ a third of raw records are excluded; see https://nycpropertymarket.com/methodology)._