# NYC Property Market: methodology

> How we turn official NYC deed records into market statistics, and the limits of what they can show.

**Canonical page:** https://nycpropertymarket.com/methodology  
**Version:** 1.0 (July 2026)

## What counts as a market sale

Roughly a third of raw Department of Finance sale records are not arm's-length transactions. We exclude them from every price metric and classify each excluded record:

- **$0 transfers**: deed corrections, gifts, transfers between related parties.
- **Nominal price**: recorded price at or below $10,000, not a market exchange.
- **Statistical outliers**: prices beyond per-segment (borough × property type × sale year) percentile fences.
- **Timeshare intervals**: weeks sold in hotel buildings (a hotel lot selling 50+ times a year at a median under $150,000).
- **Co-op block transfers**: one transfer-tax return that conveys three or more co-op apartments at once (a sponsor's or an investor's block), which the Department of Finance records as a single apartment's sale at the whole price; the City Register (ACRIS) shows the units.

A sale of several lots on one deed is recorded once per lot, each with the whole price, so it counts once. Sales on one block on the same day at the same price that the City Register (ACRIS) shows as separate deeds to different buyers, such as a developer's identical houses, count separately.

Only records classified as arm's-length market sales feed the medians, counts and $/ft² figures.

## How metrics are computed

- **Medians, not averages**, with 25th/75th-percentile context. Every figure carries its sample size (n).
- **Suppression**: statistics are withheld below 5 sales (medians) or 5 (per-ft²); year-over-year change needs 8+ sales in both periods.
- **$/ft² only where floor area is reliable**: houses and whole buildings. Never for condo or co-op units, because city sale records carry no unit-level square footage; never from a recorded area under 300 ft², nor above $20,000/ft² (a development site, priced for its land).
- **Co-ops** are DOF classes C6, C8, D0, D4 and R9 (a co-op inside a condominium); a building's page lists each sale with its apartment.
- **Condos** are residential condo units. Commercial condo units (offices, retail, hotels, the commercial unit of a small building) count as commercial; parking, storage and other non-residential units as other property, as does class R5, under which the Department of Finance filed every non-residential condo unit until 2012.

## Sales filled from the City Register (ACRIS)

Each of these is marked in its property's sale history.

- **Co-op sales of June to December 2010** (8,821): the Department of Finance's annual file for 2010 has none, so they come from the transfer-tax returns recorded in ACRIS. Where both records exist (January to May 2010) they agree on lot, price and date for 98.7% of co-op sales.
- **Sales the yearly files miss** (15,228, 2005 to mid-2025): deeds recorded after a yearly file was compiled, and new condominiums' first closings before their apartments are listed. Deeds and transfer-tax returns for one residential property and a full interest, over $10,000, leaving out transfers between people who share a surname and transfers split across several documents. Since July 2025 the monthly files pick up most late recordings.
- **Deed dates** (11,353, mostly 2003–2007): the Department of Finance's date in those years often follows the deed's recording by weeks or months; where the register shows exactly one deed on the lot for the same amount, we use the deed's date.
- **As-of dates and sources on every figure.** Data refreshes monthly from NYC Open Data.

## Known limitations

- Recorded sale prices are what was filed on the deed, not an appraisal or an estimate of current value.
- Late-recorded sales appear retroactively; figures for recent months can revise upward.
- Co-op transactions are share transfers; unit-level detail is limited compared with condos and houses.

---

_Source: NYC Department of Finance & City Planning via NYC Open Data. Not affiliated with the City of New York. https://nycpropertymarket.com_